NAFI is wrong on that book

Dr. Barry Traill, Australian Woodlands Conservancy, Chiltern, The Age (letter), 24/4/99


Logging has caused local extinctions of native animals in many regions. This simple fact has been systematically ignored by the National Association of Forest Industries (NAFI) in claiming that statements on threats of extinction in the  book Forest-Friendly Building Timbers are ‘deceitful, misleading and unscientific’ (The Age 21/4).

It is NAFI’s claims that are, at best, misleading and unscientific.  Recent research has shown that Yellow-bellied Gliders in Victoria’s Central Highlands are now virtually absent from Mountain Ash forests used for intensive timber production.  My own research in Box-Ironbark forests indicates that there have been local extinctions of some birds and a mammal due to forestry practices removing mature trees from large areas.  Such local extinctions can ultimately lead to the final global extinction of a species.  Local extinctions can also affect the normal ecological functions and health of a forest.

Amongst researchers who have studied the effects of logging on flora and fauna there is a broad consensus that current intensive logging and woodchipping practices are not ecologically sustainable.  I challenge the National Association of Forest Industries to talk to leading wildlife researchers and inform themselves of the latest findings on the effects of intensive logging operations.  Until they do, wildlife researchers, and I suspect the general public, will continue to laugh at their claims of having science on their side.