Jumping on the fire wagon

Gavan McFadzean, Victorian campaigns manager, the Wilderness Society

The Age (letter), 23/1/03

Back to Letters Back to Forest Letter Watch


The National Association of Forest Industries' statements calling for national parks around Melbourne to be burned to reduce fire risk (The Age, 22/1) have nothing to do with the current fire crisis, but are an opportunistic ploy to press their anti-national park case.

Contrary to popular opinion, most fires start outside parks and burn in. The 1983 Ash Wednesday and 1939 Black Friday fires were mostly in regrowth forests recovering from logging - while in national parks and wildlife reserves of NSW between 1974 and 1984, 65 fires began outside reserves and burnt into them, compared with 14 fires that began in reserves and burnt out into other land.

If NAFI really cared about public safety, they would be calling for a moratorium on logging during this crisis, because logging makes forests more fire-prone. Huge amounts of debris are left on the forest floor after logging, and logged areas cause a drying out of the surrounding forest, adding to the fire hazard.

Moreover, as Michael Fendley pointed out, 75 per cent of fires are started by humans, either through arson or by accident - and logging roads increase public access into forest areas.


Back to Letters Back to Forest Letter Watch